- 研究生: 許子涵
- 論文名稱: 2001年選舉文宣傳播效益性別分析之先遣研究
- 論文名稱: Gender Analysis on Campaign Ads:A Pioneering Study on 2001's Legislator Election
- 指導教授: 王雅各 博士
- 關鍵字: 選舉文宣 傳播效益 性別分析 高教育程度選民
-
[摘要]
西方的研究顯示,女人的投票意向對選舉結果有越來越大的影響,且女性與男性在投票決
定上有很大的考量差異,出現「性別溝」的現象。九0年代後,台灣的婦女團體開始對婦
女參與政治投予關注,逐漸重視呼籲女性作為一個集團,因為性別考量而投票。台灣女性
在投票意向上越來越自主,女性的投票決定也越來越能影響選舉結果。但是這種女性特殊
投票意向之形成,及其所造成之影響,卻少有研究論及。本研究以2001年舉行的第五屆立
法委員以及第十四屆縣市長選舉時的選舉文宣為資料,首先進行文宣內容分析,並輔以深
度訪談法來蒐集閱聽人閱覽文宣後之感想,進行此先遣性研究。
本研究試圖以性別為區辨變項,探討對高教育程度的受訪者而言,選舉文宣之傳播效益是
否會因性別差異而有不同呈現?希望藉由在選舉文宣傳播效益之研究上,加上「性別分析
」之角度,對兩性投票意向決定過程以及其影響因素做初步的探索,以便對這個領域所呈
現出來的現象有大略的理解,並作為日後有志者繼續研究之前例。
研究發現選舉文宣所具有之傳播效益不應侷限在行為效果層次上,文宣對選民的情感∕態
度之認同以及對候選人的認識上,有更肯定的影響。兩性同樣都偏好正面取向文宣,也認
為議題取向文宣較具說服、認知效果。而對高教育程度的受訪者而言,影響選舉文宣傳播
效益之主要因素並不是性別,而是其原本既有之政黨傾向、候選人偏好、媒體使用情形、
家人影響之大小等因素。
-
[摘要]
Many studies have been focusing on election related issues. For the past few
decades, research has consistently indicating the weight (and meaning) of women
’s voting. Put simply, literature (at least in the U.S.) shows the growing
significance of women’s voting in determining the result of election. As a
result, terms such as gender gap, voting block, and / or gender crossing
voting have gained extensive attention from many scholars.
This research attempts to forge political sociology (in campaign ads), media
effects (audience study) and gender study into an unified perspective. Using
the 2001 legislator election as a case, I adopt content analysis and in-depth
interview to probe whether campaign ads have gender differences in its
communication effects.
The paper finds, as contrary to conventional studies, that campaign ads mainly
exert impact on attitudinal and cognitive dimensions. This finding along
refutes the traditional view which asserts campaign ads can make voter vote
—if the ads are effective. Other findings include that both sexes favor
positive ads, acknowledge the effects of issue-oriented ads toward persuasion,
and that after controlling education, gender along actually has little impact
on cognition. In all, the study suggests that gender, in combination with
other variables, may be a crucial and yet (up until now) a seriously neglected
factor in our understanding on the effectiveness of campaign ads. Additionally,
future studies may put more emphases on the emotional and cognitive side
rather than focus exclusively on the behavioral dimension.