校園一隅

三鶯研究

首頁 > 學生表現 > 三鶯研究>歷屆碩士班論文

台灣公私部門與階級意識關係之研究
(碩士班:黃承勇) (指導教授:沈幼蓀)

刊登日期:2004-01-31  
友善列印


  • 出版年 :2004
  • 研究生 :黃承勇
  • 論文名稱 :台灣公私部門與階級意識關係之研究
  • 英文論文名稱 :The Research for Class Consciousness and Public and Private Sector in Taiwan
  • 指導教授 :沈幼蓀
  • 學位類別 :碩士
  • 論文頁數 :85
  • 關鍵詞 :階級 ; 階級意識 ; 公私部門
  • 英文關鍵詞 :class ; class consciousness ; public and private sector
  • [ 摘要 ]

    根據 Wright 的模式,階級位置與階級行動對於階級意識有著重要的影響力。然而,在社會中,卻也存在著許多不同的因素可能會對於階級意識產生影響。而國家即可能為影響因素之一。受雇於公部門的人因為公部門的特殊性,導致與資產階級以及私人利益間的關係不同於私部門。如此一來,兩者間就有出現不同的階級意識的可能。所以,在本研究中要探討的焦點即為公部門與私部門之間的差異會如何影響階級意識。在實際的研究中,分別從公部門與私部門之中區分出再生產資本主義部門、直接生產服務與產品部門、營利部門與非營利部門四類。在階級意識方面,則區分出三個面向,分別是階級認同、對於資本主義的態度與對於國家干預的態度進行分析,期待對於台灣的階級圖像有更深入的瞭解。在此所採用的資料為「台灣地區社會變遷基本調查資料」第四期第一次問卷 I ,共有 1960 份樣本。在研究結果中,雖然各部門間的差異並不十分顯著,仍可大略看出一些差異之處。首先,在階級認同方面,無論是中產階級或是工人階級均顯現出公部門較私部門更不認同工人階級的情況。其次,對於資本主義的態度方面,公部門亦是於中產階級與工人階級中均表現出較私部門為支持資本主義的態度。第三,在對於國家干預的態度方面,公部門則表現出較私部門更為支持國家干預的態度。最後,無論是何階級,非營利部門均較營利部門更為反對資本主義而支持國家干預。

  • [ 英文摘要 ]

    According to Wright's model, class location and class practice have great effect upon class consciousness. However, there are many different factors that may affect class consciousness in a society. Perhaps state is one of the factors. Because the speciality of public sector, individuals employed by public sector have different relationship between capitalist and private profit than those in the private sector. It could constitute a significant division of class consciousness. Therefore the purpose of this study is how the difference between public and private sector affect class consciousness. In real analysis, public sector is distinguished into the state political sector and the state service sector. Private sector is distinguished into profit sector and nonprofit sector. Class consciousness is distinguished into class identity, attitudes to capitalism and to state intervention. We hope this study can make the class image in Taiwan more clear. In this study, we use “2000 Taiwanese Social Change Survey”. From the result, though the differences between each sector are not very obvious, we can still find several differences. First, in the aspect of class identity, both middle class and working class in the public sector have less identity towards working class than those in the private sector. Second, in the aspect of the attitude of capitalism, both middle class and working class in the public sector are more supportive towards capitalism than those in the private sector. Third, in the aspect of the attitude towards state intervention, both middle class and working class in the public sector are more supportive towards state intervention than those in the private sector. Finally, within each class, people in the nonprofit sector are less supportive towards capitalism and are more supportive towards state intervention than those in the profit sector