校園一隅

碩士/碩專班畢業論文

首頁 > 學生表現 > 碩士/碩專班畢業論文>歷屆碩士班論文

中國大陸台商的勞動體制:以自行車台商為例
(碩士班:楊承祥) (指導教授:沈幼蓀)

刊登日期:2007-01-31  
友善列印


  • 研究生:楊承祥
  • 論文名稱:中國大陸台商的勞動體制:以自行車台商為例
  • 指導教授:沈幼蓀
  • 關鍵字:中國台商 ; 自行車產業 ; 勞動體制
  • [摘要]

    以往台灣的出口企業以中小企業所組成的協力網絡為主,採用垂直分工的「彈性化生產」,依賴大量的外包來完成產品,而到了大陸設廠之後,則傾向採用廠內雇工的生產模式。本研究主要在探討台商在不同勞動力市場環境之下,相同產業而生產組織不同的企業,如何運用來自不同背景的勞動力、產生怎麼樣的勞動體制以及他們跟大陸員工的權力關係、相處模式是呈現什麼樣的面貌。

    在相關理論文獻方面,本研究回顧了傳統馬克思的勞動理論、Braverman的去技術化命題、Burawoy的工廠體制、工廠制與外包制的比較以及相關台商勞動體制的研究。本研究採取質化研究方法,選定自行車產業,實地至中國深圳、上海、江蘇、浙江等地進行田野研究,針對個案進行深度訪談,並配合參與觀察。

    研究發現,台商在中國,相較於在台灣,呈現出較為專制的勞動體制,在管理上採用軍事化管理,在生產上則傾向泰勒化的生產組織。採取軍事化管理的主要原因在於台商與大陸員工文化上的差異以及對大陸員工的不信任。而因為兩岸分工的關係,台商在大陸工廠生產少樣多量、技術成分低的低單價產品,適合泰勒化的生產組織,同時比較能容忍較高的員工流動率。而台商勞動體制所帶來的意識型態效果則是「打工意識」。

    在研究過程中,可以發現三個重要的因素影響著大陸台商的勞動體制,即大陸勞動力市場的發展、生產組織的變化以及兩岸文化背景的差異。中國大陸的二元勞動力市場,提供大量廉價的勞動力,加上台商與地方官僚有一種共生的關係,這種政商關係形成中國勞動力市場中暫時性的「國家缺席」,國家外部規範工具和廠內體制高度斷裂,呈現出「市場專制勞動體制」。而在全球商品鍊中,台商在大陸從事的是低技術性勞力密集的生產活動,產品市場競爭較激烈,必須降低勞動條件以提高競爭力。再加上文化上的差異,使得台商不易信任大陸員工,這些因素形塑了台商在大陸的勞動體制。


  • [ 英文摘要 ]

    In the past, Taiwanese small and medium-sized enterprises used to adopt vertical labor division within pulling network, rely on a large amount of outsourcing to complete the production. After setting up business in China, they incline to adopt the hired labor mode of production in the factory. This study discuss the labor regime of Taiwanese bicycle business in the different environment between China and Taiwan, including how do the same industry organize production in different places, how to use the workforces from different backgrounds, and what's their power relationship with Chinese staff, through qualitative fieldwork and in-depth interview in Shenzhen, Shanghai, Jiangsu, Zhejiang.

    There are three important factors effected the labor regime of the Taiwanese business in China, as the characteristic of the labor market, the change of production organization, and the difference of culture backgrounds. First, the labor market of China offers a large amount of low-priced workforces while Taiwanese business and Chinese local bureaucrat have relationship of intergrowth, which formed 'state absentionism' in the Chinese labor market and construct the labor regime of Taiwanese business in China as 'market despotic regime'. Second, in the ‘global commodity chain', it is the low technical labor's intensive activity in production that Taiwanese business engaged in China, so they adopt the Taylor production organization to suit the low-end products under the labor division in Taiwan and China, and because of the competition of the products in market are relatively fierce, producer must reduce the work condition in order to improve the competitiveness, which cause the higher employee turnover rate. Third, culture difference makes Taiwanese business difficult to trust Chinese staff and become more autocratic and militarized in management. All those cause the ideological effect of the labor regime of Taiwanese business result as ' temporary labor consciousness '.